HP Elite X2 1012 review: not just another Surface Pro clone

By on
HP Elite X2 1012 review: not just another Surface Pro clone

This hybrid laptop hits the mark with business-friendly features.

Hybrid laptops have risen to become a popular fixture of the PC landscape, thanks in no small part to Microsoft's excellent Surface Pro range, which proved that 2-in-1s can be both portable and powerful.

You may be tempted to think that HP's Elite X2 1012 is just another Surface Pro knock-off, given the similarities between the two devices. Look under the surface, however, and you'll find a machine that's more than worthy of any professional's time.


The design of Microsoft's Surface Pro range has inspired many copycat devices over the past few years, and HP's Elite X2 1012 is one of them. Like the Surface Pro, it has a detachable metal keyboard and a fold-out kickstand to turn it from a tablet to a laptop and back again.

Surface Pro clones don't always offer the same rewarding experience as Microsoft's original tablet, but thankfully one of the things that HP has borrowed from Microsoft is a sleek and professional design sensibility. It's built from aluminium with a matte finish, and shares the Surface Pro's attractive and streamlined look, with a casing that also promises sturdiness and reliability.

As with all of its enterprise-grade machines, HP has put those promises of build quality to the test. The Elite X2 has been put through a huge range of trials to ensure that it can withstand a creditable amount of punishment; the kickstand can be opened and shut ten thousand times, the keyboard has been rated for ten million keystrokes and the device itself has been drop-tested from a height of more than half a metre onto concrete.

At 820g heavy minus the keyboard, it's a touch bulkier than the most recent Surface Pro. However, it's still far from unwieldy, and it's absolutely no trouble to cart around for the duration of a working day. In fact, it's even a touch thinner, at 8.2mm.

The biggest aesthetic difference between the Elite X2 and the Surface Pro is that the X2 uses a cut-out frame for its kickstand, rather than the full plate version used by Microsoft. While this could be slightly more versatile than the Surface Pro, we'd worry that it doesn't offer the same stability and structural integrity as a full plate version, and that it'd break more easily.

HP does have an ace up its sleeve, though, and that's user upgradeability. Pop out a couple of screws and you can get at the internal hardware, allowing you to replace components like the RAM, storage and screen.

This is a real selling-point for more technical users or businesses with laptop fleets – many manufacturers don't make it easy to access the internal workings of their hardware, and if you need to send a machine back to the manufacturer every time an individual component fails, that can quickly become expensive. It's much cheaper to do simple component changes yourself – or have them done by your in-house IT team.


Unsurprisingly, the Elite X2's 12.3in screen is another high point; HP generally has a good reputation with regards to its display technology, and that reputation is upheld here. The colour accuracy was very good indeed, covering a whopping 91.5% of the sRGB colour spectrum, and the maximum brightness of 388cd/m2 and 2736 x 1824-pixel display resolution are similarly hard to fault. It's made from Gorilla Glass 4 too, so you can be confident that it won't shatter easily.

If there's one fault with the screen, it's that it doesn't feature any form of matte anti-glare coating. This feature has been cropping up on more and more laptops, and it makes working under tricky lighting conditions much more manageable. However, given that we've yet to see an anti-glare coating combined with Corning's excellent Gorilla Glass, we're happy to make a minor compromise on convenience for the sake of strength and stability.


You'd be forgiven for thinking that HP would struggle to match up to the exceptionally high standards set by Microsoft's TypeCover keyboards, but you'd be wrong. The Elite X2's folio keyboard is an absolute delight to use.

The aluminium keyboard frame ensures that the keyboard is solid and stable while you're typing, with the added benefit that it adds an air of sophisticated professionalism that Microsoft's colourful keyboards sometimes lack.

The actual typing action is lovely too, offering crisp, defined feedback and an impressive travel depth, considering the relative slimness of the keyboard. Rattling off long passages of text using the X2's keyboard is an absolute breeze, and although we very slightly prefer the Surface Pro's keyboard, there really isn't that much in it.

It uses magnetic detachment, as is pretty much standard for this type of hybrid, and slots home with a satisfying thunk. The trackpad is nice too. It's not quite as large as we would have liked, but it's smooth, fluid and supports multitouch gestures.

In addition to the usual input methods, the X2 also supports HP's Active Pen, which costs $109 or is bundled with some models. It's not quite as polished an experience as rival styluses like Microsoft's Surface Pen or the Apple Pencil, but writing with it feels fluid and natural enough to cope with basic drawing or note-taking, if not detailed artistic tasks.

Next: performance, battery life, features, pricing and verdict

Performance and battery life

The HP Elite X2 1012 is available in a range of configurations. Our test unit included Intel Core i7-7600U processor, 16GB of RAM and 512GB Turbo Drive SSD. It racked up a score of 53 in our benchmark tests, which is speedy indeed. While it lagged a little bit behind an equivalent Surface Pro model, it's more than capable of keeping up with most other 2-in-1s and even some ultrabooks, and will happily handle intense workloads and multitasking without a hint of complaint.

Battery life is a less impressive story, unfortunately. In our video rundown test, it managed just 6 hours 32 minutes, which isn't as lengthy as we'd like. In fact, it's probably not going to see you through a full working day unless you're judicious about limiting your power consumption. This is a shame, as it limits the versatility of an otherwise excellent hybrid.

Ports and features

As one of HP's business devices, the Elite X2 is more generous than most Surface Pro-type devices when it comes to ports. Along with a USB 3.0 port, there's a Thunderbolt-enabled USB-C port allowing it to be connected to a powered dock for data, power and display transfer. It also has a MicroSD card slot for expanding the storage and a SIM tray for 4G data connectivity.

There's a depth-sensing camera offering Windows Hello biometric login support, and all but the entry-level models include Windows 10 Pro as standard, offering a range of enterprise management functions. HP has included several of its own business management tools as well, including third-generation Sure Start BIOS protection and the HP Manageability Integration Kit.

Pricing and conclusion

The HP Elite X2 1012 starts at $1,299 for a fairly basic tablet-only model, which includes an Intel Core i3-7100U processor, 4GB of RAM, 128GB solid state drive and Windows 10 Home. There’s a wide range of other prices and configurations available, but if you can bump up your budget to $2,399, you’ll get an Intel Core i5-7300U chip, 8GB of RAM, high-performance ‘Turbo Drive’ 256GB SSD, Windows 10 Pro and the keyboard included.

The model we tested goes for $3,199 but that includes the keyboard, 4G capability, Intel Core i7-7600U processor, 16GB of RAM and 512GB Turbo Drive SSD. While that’s not particularly cheap, it is $100 less than an equivalent Surface Pro – and the latter doesn't include keyboard.

The HP Elite X2 1012 is a sterling example of how to do a business hybrid right. It may take a substantial amount of inspiration from Microsoft's Surface Pro range, but HP hasn't fallen into the trap that many manufacturers fall into by only borrowing the design and forgetting about the impressive performance that makes the Surface Pro line so beloved.

On top of that, the company has also added some very useful features, such as a raft of management tools and the ability to upgrade parts, which will make techies and IT administrators very happy indeed.

This review is based on an article that originally appeared at IT Pro.

HP Elite X2 1012
4 5
Battery life isn’t great, but the HP Elite X2 1012 is otherwise an excellent hybrid laptop that offers a wide range of configurations, top-notch screen and keyboard, and some features you won’t find in a Surface Pro – including management tools and the ability to upgrade parts.
From $1299 AUD
12.3in touchscreen display with 2736 x 1824-pixel resolution; Intel Core i3-7100U, Core i5-7300U or Core i7-7600U processor; 4GB, 8GB or 16GB of RAM; 128GB SATA SSD or 256GB, 512GB or 1TB Turbo Drive SSD; 1 USB 3.1 Type-C with Thunderbolt, 1 USB 3.0, 1 microSD, 1 SIM; dual-band 802.11ac Wi-Fi, Bluetooth 4.2; fingerprint reader, IR Camera for face authentication; Windows 10 Home or Pro.
Multi page
Copyright © ITPro, Dennis Publishing

Most Read Articles

You must be a registered member of Business IT to post a comment.
| Register


How long has your business been operating?
Up to 2 years
2-5 years
5-10 years
More than 10 years
View poll archive

Log In

Username / Email:
  |  Forgot your password?