Rudd's New NBN: Five upsides, five downsides

By on
Rudd's New NBN: Five upsides, five downsides

Kevin Rudd's announcement yesterday that, in effect, the winner of the NBN process was nobody was something of a jaw-dropping moment. Should broadband users be overjoyed by the NBN, or cautiously wary?

The announcement that the Government would instead invest $43 billion in a FTTH network was even more jaw dropping. But what are the real upsides, and for that matter, the downsides?

Five reasons to be optimistic:

  • 1) Promised speed increases: Up to 100Mbit, and potentially even faster again in the future.
  • 2) An open, wholesale network: Sales competition should be pretty fierce, which can only be good for customers.
  • 3) Telcos working together: Even Telstra's saying this will be a good thing -- and it'll be easier to get the NBN off the ground with Telstra than without it
  • 4) Jobs, Jobs, Jobs, Jobs: The promise of jobs -- in building, implementation and maintenance -- can only be a good thing.
  • 5) Starting this year: Tasmania this year, so it's claimed. Covering the broadband blackspots first is clever strategy.

Five reasons to be pessimistic:

  • 1) Political hurdles: Special interests. Opposition. Just plain political meddling. Anyone think that's not going to happen?
  • 2) A motza of money: $43 billion, and then similar private investment -- if it can be found.
  • 3) Eight years to complete: Eight years is a long, long time in broadband.
  • 4) Government owned: Can anyone say "mandatory filter"?
  • 5) Not Government owned: But they're also planning to sell it off after 5 years. Did failing to separate Telstra before selling it really work out?

Most Read Articles


What would you like to see more of on BiT?
How To's
Photo Galleries
View poll archive

Log In

  |  Forgot your password?